Running out of ideas for a new post, I
stumbled upon an
article about
“leaving feminism.” While reading, I grew more and more annoyed after each line. The author's lessons on feminism taught her entirely different ideas than all the sources I have ever read. I could spend hours, pages, and
way too many words going over why the “feminist teachings” that made her leave
feminism were read entirely wrong, but that would be a waste of all our time. Although I didn't like
her overall post, she makes one good point about the “quick to speak
before thinking” that some (maybe more vocal) feminists do.
For instance (looking at only one point from the article) one reaction from feminists that made this author want to quit the movement was: “Real equality is when women have the right to be as drunk and stupid as men,” instead of taking self-defense or learning to watch out for drugged drinks. But by making this point they were missing the real issues behind it, as I think the author was when she decided to throw in the towel.
The author wrote: “Do feminists really care about women’s safety at all?
Or do they care more about their dream world..?” I don’t know who you have
been talking to, but the feminists I know care very much about the safety of
women. So much so that it’s one of the goals of feminism to create a world
where women can feel safe, where women can drink as much as they want to at
parties without worrying about what might happen to them, where they can walk
down the street at night and not be so afraid of the figure heading their
direction that they cross the street to avoid them. We want women to be safe,
(so safe that they might never need self-defense classes) but there must be
major changes made to this world before that can ever happen.
In a feminist’s dream world:
*girls are thought to be careful because
there are dangers out there while boys are also taught that the kind of
behavior that puts girls in danger is unacceptable.
*girls are taught to protect themselves but boys are
also taught that there are real consequences if they victimize women.
*the sexually assaulted are taught that they are
not to blame for what has happened to them and the rapists are taught that they
are the only ones responsible.
*In a feminist's dream
world, women are safe AND they can drink as much as much as men. Effort
behind this goal must come from all sides before we can say things like "men
and women should be able to drink the same amount at
parties," and before we can forget about the current obstacles that
come along with that idea.
There were many, many, other parts of the article that I would love to argue over, but I think it would make me too angry to do so.
Instead, I have this message for the author: don’t leave feminism; comment where you see problems and improve feminism. What is feminism to one person is not feminism to everyone. One person’s blurted statement is only a part of the larger conversation. It is up to the rest of us find the rest of the pieces. When it all comes down to it, a feminist is “someone who believes in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes.” Don’t quit it because someone says something problematic; be the next voice that challenges that idea, and keep the original goal going.
Maybe the author that you are referring to doesn't understand exactly what feminism is? I feel like there are a lot of people who simply just don't know what it means to be a feminist or have been misinformed and believe that feminists are just man hating women. I enjoyed your description of a feminist's dream world and I totally agree with you, but I also think that there is more than one "definition" of what is/makes someone a feminist.
ReplyDeleteYou might enjoy reading this article and the video along with it: http://hellogiggles.com/sdsu-student-asks-feminists
You're trying to describe three different viewpoints: yours, the person who wrote an article, and things a third party said/did that the article writer either agreed or disagreed with. And I can't keep them all straight -- with the result that I don't know what your stance on the some of the things is.
ReplyDeleteMy perspective is that personal responsibility is important. Why? Because perfect safety, an absolute absence of risk, will never happen. So neither men nor women should think that "getting stupid drunk" is ok, and neither men nor women think the world should be changed so as to allow it.